doubleportion wrote:How many of you used this book in your book basket during week 4 of Adventures? I have previewed it and am undecided on how my sensitive dd would handle this book. Opinions and experiences with it would be helpful. How did you talk about or explain the story to your children. I don't know enough about the Algonquin (sp?) Indians religion to be able to refute the questions this story may bring up, and then compare it with what we know as truth. Or do you just present it as an Indian fairy tale and leave it at that?
Edie
Post Posted Tue Jul 29, 2008 3:55 pm by henryteachersWe absolutely loved this book. If you explain it as an Indian fairy tale and relate it to the familiar Cinderella tale, I think your family will enjoy it too. I loved how it taught that true beauty lies within and that faith, courage,and kindness conquers all. We had just made wigwams and teepees for a project with Adventures so it was fun to see this in the book too. I don't think you'll be disappointed. If I remember correctly, I think the Hazels gave the book a star* by it which mean it is excellent and you don't want to miss out on it.
P.S.--Their God is mentioned as the invisible being so you could also mention that they believe differently than you do and call God something else.
Post Posted Tue Jul 29, 2008 6:12 pm by TurnOurHeartsWe used it as a VERY gentle springboard for discussing wrong beliefs/belief systems and how they can SOUND very similar to things we hold as truth. There are so many homeschool curricula that introduce other gods as major themes in their early-year programs. MFW concentrates on God as the one true God from day one. We had no problem talking though this book (spiritually) and we enjoyed it very much, too. Personally, I don't think we have to know everything about other religions. It's kind of the philosophy that you've heard of with FBI agents who work against counterfeit money? They can't know all the counterfeit possibilities ~ they just learn the original article so well that they can spot a fake a mile away. The closer we walk with the Genuine Article, the more convinced we become of His power & authority.
Also, I find with my kids the simpler the explanation, the better. They don't want or need as much info as we sometimes want to give. And don't be afraid to tell them, "I don't know. We'll have to look that up." That's good stuff, too.

(Sorry if I'm rambling all over tonight ~ it's been a long day! Hope this makes sense!!)
Post Posted Wed Jul 30, 2008 9:18 pm by AriasariasMy girls loved the story and still ask for it. I think it is because it so closely resembles Cinderella which has also been a very big character teacher for us -- kindness, service, hope, contentment, etc.
Post Posted Tue Aug 26, 2008 11:47 am by cbollinI decided to go check out this book and use it during ECC weeks 3 and 4 with US study a couple of weeks ago.
Oh wow! What a great story. Maybe it is the looking back 5 years or whatever, but what I saw in this story was how eternity was written on their hearts even tho the details got a little confused after the years and no longer were the real deal (like Paige had in her analogy about the money). I don't know if any of you have read that book in your adult life to understand that connection. But what a connection is there! wow!!! Are you remembering to teach your children how to use those things to present the right thing? Didn't Paul have to do that in Athens with the statue to the unknown god??? anyway.... sorry 'bout that
then there was the character lessons that were there just in the story.
just one opinion. I liked the book.
-crystal